Managers of commercial, industrial
and institutional buildings
are always on the lookout for
ways to reduce their cost of operations,
including maintenance expenses and heating
and cooling bills.
For help, one powerful tool they’ve
turned to is a handheld thermal imager,
also known as infrared (IR) imagers or IR
cameras.
Thermal imaging or thermography can
capture two-dimensional representations
of surface temperatures, including roofs,
walls, doors, windows and construction
joints. Often, these images reveal temperatures
or differences in temperatures (Dts)
that indicate conditions and inefficiencies
contributing to the waste of heated or
cooled air and energy.
While thermography may be used for tasks as diverse as detecting insect or animal
infestations and discovering voids in
poured concrete structures, they also can
help lower a building’s maintenance and
energy costs by checking roofs, walls,
windows and doors for inefficiencies.
Flat roof structures are the standard in
commercial, industrial and institutional
buildings in the U.S., and billions of dollars
are lost every year due to premature
roof failure. By simply maintaining the
roof, a great deal of money that is being
lost could be put to better use. Infrared
roof inspection can help prolong the life
of a flat roof structure.
A flat (low-slope) roof consists of a
deck, insulation and a membrane. Usually,
the membrane consists of either built-up
layers of roofing felts bonded together, or
it’s a single sheet of glued down rubber
or plastic further anchored by stone ballast.
The membrane’s job is to keep out
water. When a membrane leaks, water is
exposed to the insulation.
Using methods outlined here, it is relatively
easy to isolate moisture in or on insulation
during an external inspection
using an IR camera. In fact, one thermography
expert says that finding water problems
on a flat roof, especially finding water-
saturated insulation is like “shooting
fish in a barrel.”
Of course, wet insulation loses its Rrating,
which means it loses its effectiveness
as a barrier against heat and cold and
should be replaced.
If a roof leaks but the insulation
does not absorb water, then you need
more than a passing knowledge of insulation
types and of patterns caused by
water infiltration to perform meaningful thermography yourself. Still, if you know
that the roof construction on your building(
s) is built up felts with absorbent insulation
(e.g., perlite, wood fiber, cork or
fiberglass), then an investment in an IR
camera may be the way to go in guarding
against heating or cooling losses and/or
expensive roof repairs.
Walls
During an external scan of a building
under the right circumstances, a thermal
imager can pinpoint moisture in walls in
much the same way it can in roofs. Of
course, water in walls (or roofs) will lead
to mold and mildew, adversely affecting
occupants who are allergic to such spores. Also, in walls (as in roofs), wet absorbent
insulation will have lost its effectiveness
and should be replaced.
Detecting totally non-insulated walls
poses a special problem because there is
no insulated section with which to compare
non-insulated sections. When thermal
readings are uniform for a wall, a
physical inspection of the wall’s interior
may be required to confirm the presence
of insulation.
To monitor for air leakage, which generally
translates into cooling losses in summer
and heating losses in winter, scan
windows, closed doors, construction joints
(soffits and transitions from concrete to
frame walls), wall penetrations ( pipes and
electrical entries) and roof penetrations
(vents, ducts and chimneys). Under the right
circumstances, an IR camera will detect
temperature differences that signal heating
or cooling losses.
In double-pane window systems, for
example, vacuum seals inevitably erode
over time, and moisture collecting between
the panes of glass signal that condition.
When that happens, an infrared
camera scanning a bank of windows from
the outside will confirm the seal loss by recording a surface temperature of the suspect
window different from the other windows
in the bank. The R-value of the
window is different because the insulation
seal is gone.
While infrared thermography is useful
in finding seals that are broken or completely
missing on window systems,
there is a fairly long payback on repairing
windows as compared to other ways
of reducing the cost of operations.
As one experienced thermographer puts
it, “There are usually bigger energy fish
to fry somewhere else in the building.”
That is, a savvy manager is probably going
to start with fixes that represent the
fastest return on investment, addressing
roofing problems, for example, before
dealing with windows that have lost their
seals.
One other often-overlooked area of energy
loss are doors at shipping and receiving
docks. Nearly every commercial,
industrial or institutional building, no matter
how small an operation it supports, has
a loading dock. Except in the rare case
when the docks are not heated and cooled
for the comfort of workers, the potential
for wasting energy when a truck is at a
dock is significant. Thermal images will
help document the extent of any waste.
When and What to Look For?
Wet insulation is the primary cause of
premature roof failures and high roof
maintenance costs. Scan roofs after a hot
day. Any detectable moisture will retain
the heat of the day while surrounding
structures and insulation cool.
In a report by Infrared Solutions Inc.,
now a Fluke company, Chaz Nabji notes
that different types of insulation result
in different thermal patterns. Therefore,
knowing what type of insulation is in a
roof and the thermal pattern it will create
in the presence of water can be very
helpful in detecting moisture in a roofing
system.
Nanji makes the following observations:
At dusk, wet, absorbent insulation
will appear thermally as a warm
area, but water runs off non-absorbent
insulation and collects in insulation
joints. In this case, a thermal image
will take on a “window frame” pattern.
By contrast, foam glass block insulation
will only allow water to fill in surface
pores. Then, if the water freezes,
it will expand and cause the insulation
to crack, resulting in a “fractured”
pattern.